Skip to content
Multifamily houses supply passive revenue, are exhausting to search out on Lengthy Island

Angelica Cocha, an agent with EXP Realty in Hampton Bays, obtained greater than 100 inquiries for a rental home a number of months in the past, main her to carry an open home, one thing she had by no means executed.

Low stock and excessive demand proceed to make it troublesome for tenants within the neighborhoods she works in to search out rental models, and for buyers like her to search out multifamily homes to purchase and lease out.

Cocha, 39, a resident of East Quogue, immigrated to the USA from Ecuador in 2006, and has specialised in working with Latino patrons and renters for seven years.

“There’s a large marketplace for them, and they’re investing in rental properties too, not simply as first-time homebuyers,” she stated.

Single-family houses account for 80% of the housing in Suffolk County, and 77% in Nassau, in accordance with census information. That leaves simply 20% in Suffolk and 23% in Nassau for all different sorts — condo buildings with a whole lot of models, two-family homes and the whole lot in between.

In 2021, about 42% of all residential models in the actual property market throughout the nation had been multifamily buildings, in accordance with, a supplier of market and client information. That is nearly double that of Lengthy Island.

Whereas the Island has far fewer multifamily homes than the remainder of the nation, actual property buyers look to those properties to generate revenue by renting out the models, typically holding on to the properties lengthy time period as their values enhance.

Nonetheless, excessive dwelling values and mortgage rates of interest have been stopping buyers from shopping for within the present market, some consultants say.

Angelica Cocha owns a number of rental properties, together with this one in Flanders. Credit score: James Carbone

It is actually lots of competitors for the tenants. It may be unhappy.

— Angelica Cocha

Cocha owns a number of rental properties, together with a multifamily home in Flanders that she stated she’s going to by no means promote. She purchased the two-unit property in 2019 for $280,000 and though she want to put money into one other, it is virtually unimaginable to search out multifamily properties for anybody who desires to purchase one in that space.

“When one thing comes up, buyers actually soar on it,” she stated.

She has once in a while inspired purchasers renting a two-family home to purchase the property as quickly as the owner is prepared to promote.

42% of residential models within the U.S. are multi-family buildings,

in accordance with On LI, census information exhibits residences that aren’t single-family houses account for

20% in Suffolk


23% in Nassau.

With a robust want for rental models on the East Finish due to excessive demand, many staff in Riverhead and Flanders are pressured to search for leases farther west in Shirley and Mastic, Cocha stated. “It is actually lots of competitors for the tenants,” she stated. “It may be unhappy.”

Whereas there are some so-called inexpensive housing models out there, “I do not suppose it is sufficient,” Cocha stated.

‘A profitable enterprise’

Jason Orsini, an actual property agent with Douglas Elliman Actual Property in Plainview, works with many consumers who’ve purchased and bought multifamily houses on Lengthy Island. He additionally owns 4 multifamily properties, which have 9 tenants.

“It may be a profitable enterprise,” he stated, including that he makes greater than $80,000 a 12 months earlier than taxes on these properties.

However the present market is hard, stated Orsini, 43, of Smithtown.

“To purchase a real authorized two-family to lease as an funding, the charges are simply too excessive proper now; it is not going to become profitable,” Orsini stated. “Patrons and buyers might have to attend for charges or costs to come back down.”

Two-family properties on Lengthy Island are promoting for between $700,000 and $1 million, relying on situation and placement, Orsini stated.

“I will not contact something over $600,000,” he stated.

Credit score: Johnny Milano

To purchase a real authorized two-family to lease as an funding, the charges are simply too excessive proper now; it is not going to become profitable.

— Jason Orsini

His rental properties are in Levittown, Hicksville, St. James and Wantagh, and if he meets his objectives, he’ll have 10 leases by the point he is 50.

“It is at all times been my dream,” he stated.

Daybreak Serignese, an agent with Daniel Gale Sotheby’s Worldwide Realty in Port Washington, stated a part of the drive to put money into multifamily properties is the safety, in comparison with different investments.

“Traders suppose it is much less risky than the inventory market,” she stated. “They’ve a little bit extra management over the funding.”

Patrons must be armed with data earlier than they soar in, she stated. They need to know what the utmost lease is that they’ll cost of their neighborhood, what the bills are after which pay an acceptable value to allow them to become profitable.

Serignese’s opinion is that “In the event that they’re in search of a safe funding, that is it,” including that she does not typically see them come onto the market.

Financing these properties is tougher than shopping for a single-family, as a result of most banks require a 25% down cost.

Sights of passive revenue

Danielle Michelakos purchased her first dwelling in Lynbrook when she was 40. Credit score: Chris Ware

You’ll be able to solely work a lot extra time as a nurse, and it is exhausting. With actual property investing, it is passive revenue.

— Danielle Michelakos

After working as a neonatal intensive care nurse for 22 years, Danielle Michelakos determined final 12 months so as to add a facet gig and change into an actual property agent.

“I’ve at all times admired actual property buyers and flippers,” stated Michelakos, a 47-year-old single mom from Lynbrook who works at Compass Realty. “There is not any ceiling to your revenue. You’ll be able to solely work a lot extra time as a nurse, and it is exhausting. With actual property investing, it is passive revenue.”

When she was 40, she purchased her first home — a single-family Cape in Lynbrook — for $419,000 with 20% down. She stated she wished she put much less down and saved money for a two-family home.

Michelakos stated the dangers concerned in shopping for — analyzing the market the property is in, the potential revenue, the prices of the mortgage, the taxes — are at all times on her thoughts.

Billy Ragona flips homes for a residing however is in search of a multifamily to purchase and lease out. Credit score: Rick Kopstein

That is the top sport, to purchase one and have another person pay my mortgage.

— Billy Ragona

Billy Ragona, 39, of Elmont, purchased his first two homes in 2005 at age 21. One, he purchased as a trip home for $15,000 in Pennsylvania and rapidly bought it for about the identical value.

The second he purchased for $450,000 in North Babylon. He lived there for some time, then allowed household to reside there earlier than promoting it for a loss just a few years later, he stated.

Shortly after, he started flipping homes for a residing, principally in Nassau County.

Whereas he sometimes owns homes for one to 2 months earlier than promoting, in the event that they had been multifamily properties, “I might maintain on to them,” he stated.

He plans to purchase one finally, however he is daunted by the costs for multifamily homes proper now.

In his future multifamily home, he’s aiming to lease it for a lot of years after which reside in it when he retires, he stated.

“That is the top sport, to purchase one and have another person pay my mortgage.”

If you wish to purchase

Actual property agent Jason Orsini urges patrons of multifamily houses to do their math first to understand what their mortgage might be and the way a lot they’ll cost for lease. Ask your self: “What’s your aim? Do you wish to make a specific amount?” he stated. “Do you simply wish to cowl the mortgage and have it as a retirement property?”

Different suggestions:
Assess your revenue objectives. Orsini stated he solely invests in properties positive  to generate $1,500 to $2,000 monthly revenue.

Comply with native legal guidelines and ensure the home is a authorized true two-family home and never a “mother-daughter,” which generally requires that the proprietor reside on the premises.

Think about renovating a property earlier than renting out so there are fewer points and the houses will solely require fundamental upkeep. The common investor ought to price range about $5,000 per 12 months per property for upkeep prices — landscaping, repairs and extra. House owners would possibly wish to construct property taxes and landscaping prices into the month-to-month lease.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *