Skip to content
Inside Traded, actual property’s self-importance mirror

Allan Lebovits was prepared for the highlight. He introduced gold-rimmed sun shades.

Lebovits is the founding father of BridgeCity Capital, a Brooklyn-based firm that payments itself as a “millenial market for actual property capital.” He and Moishe Loketch, who handles enterprise growth (“work arduous, play arduous and embrace the challenges of the deal,” his bio reads), went to the U.S. Open in September to schmooze with a lender. The gang on the tennis match was stuffed with deep-pocketed financiers and actual property buyers, attending to know shoppers over a Honey Deuce or three. However from the second they entered the sector, Lebovits and Loketch felt eyes on them.

The duo have grow to be minor celebrities in actual property circles because of Traded, a social media firm widespread with business professionals. Traded posts collage-heavy photos about closed business actual property offers – suppose a most-wanted board for the deal-obsessed. And it’s caught the attention of nearly everybody with an Instagram account and an actual property bone of their physique.

Traded devotees know Lebovits even when they don’t know that they know him. He has appeared in a minimum of 22 posts on the account, often sporting aviators, a black yarmulke and ruler-straight bangs. He’s flanked by a rotating solid of associates, akin to Joel Wertzberger, smirking behind a thick beard and suspenders, and Pinny Loketch, Moishe’s father, who wears an lovely fedora and begins his bio with, “There’s a uncommon type of authenticity in a time worn traditional.”

“All over the place we walked, folks needed to take selfies with us,” mentioned Moishe Loketch.

What Loketch calls his “Mount Rushmore” of “goofy headshots” has introduced BridgeCity actual enterprise. In the identical approach a standard advert can lodge a model’s identify in a shopper’s head earlier than she ever interacts with its merchandise, a Traded submit will get the phrase out that you simply’re making offers.

When Loketch began shopping for Traded posts in 2019, it was nonetheless a fledgling account competing with conventional media firms for eyeballs. However because it grew, different lenders and brokers felt extra stress to get their faces on the market, irrespective of how foolish. For Traded, that stress means revenue.

All over the place we walked, folks needed to take selfies with us.
Moishe Loketch, BridgeCity Capital

Traded pulled in between $500 and $1,300 in every day charges from its New York Instagram posts alone, based on an evaluation of a number of days of posts. Some value nothing, whereas others climbed as excessive as $400 for a single submit. But, few folks know the place all that cash goes.

An nameless writer has constructed a profitable empire on the egos of probably the most egotistical of all professionals — business actual property brokers — with out giving up his identification. After an in depth investigation, The Actual Deal was in a position to monitor down what seems to be a minimum of one founding father of actual property’s favourite self-importance mirror (extra on that later). A dealer himself, Traded’s creator got here up within the New York actual property gridiron and has a historical past of experiments in tech and media.

Traded has confirmed to be his most influential invention but.


“A bang-up job”

Traded is a media firm constructed for the social networking age. It shares bare-bones photos representing business actual property offers in seven markets throughout the nation. The recipe is straightforward, consisting of a dealer’s headshot, the constructing leased or bought and the sale value in daring print.

The corporate’s city-specific accounts cowl transactions in seven markets: New York, Los Angeles, Chicago, Miami, Boston, New Jersey and Texas. It has additionally branched into protecting actual estate-focused enterprise capital offers. In all, Traded boasts 176,000 followers on Instagram, Twitter and Fb. Its TikTok account reveals zero posts, however current ventures into animated movies counsel that might quickly change.

Regardless that some followers could use Traded like a information supply, at its core, it’s an advert platform. Customers pay Traded to share their model with tens of hundreds of individuals, most of whom are opponents or potential shoppers.

And it’s quick. Simply hit comply with, scan your feed as you’ll every other day and catch the newest offers in snackable kind.

“It was that when the print model of The Actual Deal would come, you’d flip to the again and see what’s occurring, who’s shopping for and who’s promoting,” mentioned Greg Corbin, president of chapter and restructuring at Rosewood Realty Group. “That’s commuted over to Traded.”

Traded doesn’t pay a dime and does scant analysis. There’s no want for competing brokers to argue over who deserves credit score for a deal, as Traded simply posts whoever submits it. Now and again, the identical deal will get two posts as a result of brokers on each side purchase one. It serves up generic content material that anybody with Photoshop may make in 5 minutes. Face, constructing, greenback quantity. However the followers — and the alternatives for brand spanking new charges, new markets — carry on coming.

Till not too long ago, virtually each submit had a base value of round $250, a number of sources mentioned. Now, solely leases require cost upfront, however Traded nonetheless has loads of methods to attract in money. If you need your organization’s brand subsequent to your mug, that’ll run you $50. It’s one other $25 so as to add a word to the caption, and $100 to push your submit to the entrance of the road and get it up in 24 hours. Traded can be, not like information shops, not snobbish about deal dimension. So long as you pay a premium, all the pieces is value a submit.

In case your lease is lower than 1,000 sq. ft, you’ll need to cough up one other $200. In case your accomplice within the deal doesn’t need his or her involvement publicized, there’s one other price. Tack on $200 when you’re posting a residential deal or your sale value is lower than $1 million. Ego might be an costly companion.

On the hunt

Whereas Traded’s followers acknowledge the account’s characters, they know nothing in regards to the individual behind it. Traded’s founder — or founders — have constructed a wall of secrecy across the firm that, even after my makes an attempt to knock it down, stood as much as scrutiny.

Traded’s predominant e-mail handle,, handles all exterior communications. It didn’t deal with my interview request, although; my preliminary correspondence and follow-up have been ignored.

However hey, it’s a brand new media firm — I ought to strive talking the language. So I DM’d Traded’s predominant Instagram and Twitter accounts. Crickets.

I reached into my investigative reporting bag of methods. Utilizing LinkedIn superior search, I discovered six individuals who have labored there. They included advertising and marketing consultants, graphic designers and one researcher. Half are based mostly in New York, two are within the Philippines and one’s in Nigeria.

LinkedIn revealed a number of particulars: Dakota Pentony, a designer, serves as artistic director. Two former recruiters, Cecilia Tann and Edna Gibbs, deal with development advertising and marketing. One digital advertising and marketing supervisor lists 4 completely different ongoing gigs on her profile.

Learn extra

None of them responded to messages.

Regardless of — loads of folks in actual property are secretive. Digging deeper, I checked Traded’s registration in New York state’s company database. All restricted legal responsibility firms doing enterprise within the state have to supply fundamental info to the federal government, and even once they’re mild on particulars, they often record a minimum of one dwelling, respiratory individual.

Traded’s registration is skeletal. The corporate was integrated on Aug. 16, 2018, a parentless youngster with out a lot as a registering legal professional to tuck it into mattress at night time. The one clue that Traded has any connection to a human was its handle, a Turtle Bay apartment constructing with walnut cabinetry and soaking tubs.

I additionally looked for Traded on state and federal courtroom techniques. Courtroom instances are typically nice reporting fodder, throwing all types of firm secrets and techniques into the general public file. However even the lengthy arm of the regulation hasn’t unveiled Traded but.

Ajay Suresh, a self-taught photographer who makes a speciality of constructing portraits, is suing Traded for copyright infringement after it allegedly used considered one of his images with out his permission. One concern: he doesn’t know who Traded is. Neither does his lawyer.

You’re talking with
u2014 Traded

Traded seems to have used considered one of Suresh’s images, a generic shot of Touro School close to Penn Station, in a November 2020 submit. Unable to search out Traded itself, Suresh despatched two letters to the dealer within the picture however received no response.

The courtroom tried serving the lawsuit to Traded, however needed to accept the New York secretary of state as a result of Suresh and his legal professional couldn’t discover anyone else.

At that time, I actually hit the fuel, enlisting the enterprise search engine Spokeo. The service scans 89 million enterprise information, 130 million property information, 600 million courtroom information and 120 social networks for any folks related to a web site or e-mail handle. I attempted Traded’s predominant URL,, in addition to two e-mail addresses related to the web site. Nothing new.

I then searched the online area registry to a minimum of discover who purchased Traded’s web site. It pointed me to Domains By Proxy, an Arizona-based firm that buys net domains on behalf of people that don’t need their identities being sniffed out. The Domains By Proxy slogan stung: “Your identification is no one’s enterprise however ours.®”

All of the whereas, I used to be calling anyone I may who has appeared in Traded posts. Early adopters and late additions had loads of tales in regards to the firm, however one query remained: No, they didn’t know who was behind Traded.

Rosewood’s Corbin has appeared in a minimum of 19 posts on Traded and provided considered one of its first testimonials. He says he’s spoken with Traded on the telephone, however that’s so far as he’s gotten. “Hello, who am I talking with?” Corbin requested on one name.

“You’re talking with”

The answer to my search, as normal, was simply extra shoe leather-based. Finally, sources pointed to Eric Hedvat.

Unsurprisingly, Hedvat is a little bit of a thriller. He didn’t reply to a number of requests for remark. On LinkedIn, he calls himself an actual property tech entrepreneur and says he spent 5 years as director of acquisitions and advertising and marketing for Ben Shaoul’s Magnum Actual Property Group. In response to the New York MLS, he now works at funding gross sales brokerage Jet Actual Property.

Traded wouldn’t be Hedvat’s first enterprise in nameless actual property media. He beforehand based QueensBeans, a information weblog about Queens actual property offers that makes use of pseudonyms for its bylines. His accomplice in that enterprise was Jonathan Eshaghian, a Queens-focused investment-sales dealer with Marcus & Millichap. Eshaghian declined to remark.

Hedvat seems in two Traded posts , each of which include Shaoul.

When reached by telephone, Shaoul mentioned, “I don’t know what Traded is, man.”


You may drown a therapist within the sea of research analyzing the connection between social media and narcissism. One of many extra damning findings from the analysis is that extreme social media use boosts narcissism whereas killing self worth. Actual property brokers are a notoriously cutthroat, ego-driven bunch, so transfer that competitors to social media platforms and also you’ve received the right recipe for issues.

A Traded submit validates much less established dealmakers. Nevertheless it comes with a value: To gather the medal, you must play the sport. Confronted by the infinite feed of larger offers for larger value tags, the validation shortly fades. You’re in a hamster wheel, hooked on this dangerous model of your self, refreshing, refreshing, refreshing.

I don’t know what Traded is, man.
u2014 Ben Shaoul, Magnum Actual Property

Of their 2008 e-book, Born Digital, media students John Palfrey and Urs Gasser examine “digital natives,” the primary technology of individuals born with quick access to the web. For younger individuals who don’t know a world with out Instagram profiles, there’s no actual separation between their digital and real-life identities.

Some 14 years later, these digital natives are working telephones, attempting to chart their very own careers. They don’t simply know the way to construct a web-based repute — it’s the one factor they know.

“For youthful brokers, the publicity tied to a closing is an important factor to show, ‘I’m not simply on the market attempting arduous, I’m getting outcomes,’” mentioned David Schechtman, a veteran investment-sales dealer at Meridian Capital Group. It’s no shock younger actual property professionals wish to see their faces on Traded — it’s only a new iteration of how brokers fought to get their faces in print 20 years in the past.

For all Traded’s attract to scrappy upstarts competing for a chunk of the brokerage pie, it has one other attraction for extra seasoned professionals.

“At 47 years outdated, I don’t want press,” Schechtman mentioned. “I would like assignments and I would like closings.” Traded, he mentioned, has yielded actual leads.

It’s not simply Schechtman. Time and again, brokers mentioned Traded has grow to be a terrific funnel for leads. Even when they need to look ridiculous on Instagram, it’s value it.

“The important thing to opening the door is that ‘Hey, I acknowledge you guys,” Loketch of BridgeCity mentioned. “After I stroll within the room now, they are saying, ‘That’s the man from Traded. He’s a lender.’”

Hiten Samtani contributed reporting.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *